Every Door Direct Mail vs. a targeted mailing list: which should you use?
Updated November 22, 2026
If you want to mail a neighborhood, you have two choices. USPS Every Door Direct Mail (EDDM) delivers your piece to every address on the mail carrier routes you pick — no list needed. Or you can mail a targeted list of the specific people you want to reach. Each is the right answer for a different job.
How EDDM works
You choose carrier routes on the USPS website, print large “flat”-size mailers, bundle them by route and drop them off. Every address on the route gets one — houses, apartments and, unless you exclude them, businesses. There are no names on the pieces — they're addressed to “Local Postal Customer.” Postage per piece is low, but you pay for every door on the route and the larger pieces cost more to print.
How a targeted list works
You decide exactly who gets your mail — for example, owner-occupied homes built before 1990, absentee landlords, or the owners in one town — and print their names and addresses on any size piece. You pay for the list and for addressing, but you don't pay to reach people you didn't want.
Side by side
| EDDM | Targeted list | |
|---|---|---|
| Who gets it | Every address on the route, including renters | Only the owners you choose |
| Personalized | No — “Postal Customer” | Yes — owner's name |
| Piece size | Large flats only | Any size, including standard postcards |
| Area | Whole carrier routes | Any town or county |
| List cost | None | Yes |
| Best for | Blanket local awareness | Reaching owners and specific types of property |
When EDDM wins
- You want everyone in an area, renters included — restaurants, gyms, events, retail.
- The area is dense and you'd mail nearly every door anyway.
- Your message doesn't need a name on it.
When a targeted list wins
- You only want owners. Renters can't hire a roofer, refinance or sell the house. In rental-heavy areas, a big share of EDDM pieces land with people who can't buy.
- You want a type of owner: owner-occupied homes, older homes, high-value homes, landlords.
- Your targets are spread out across many routes, so EDDM would mean mailing thousands of doors to reach a few hundred.
- You want a personal touch. A card with the owner's name gets read.
Where EDDM reaches the most renters in Long Island (Nassau and Suffolk)
Across Long Island (Nassau and Suffolk), 85% of homes are owner-occupied. These towns have the lowest shares, so an EDDM drop there reaches the most non-owners:
- Shelter Island: 12% owner-occupied, 2,520 homes
- East Hampton: 26% owner-occupied, 19,644 homes
- Southold: 37% owner-occupied, 14,374 homes
- Southampton: 39% owner-occupied, 39,120 homes
- Long Beach: 48% owner-occupied, 8,814 homes
A middle path
Some businesses do both: EDDM for broad awareness a couple of times a year, and targeted cards to owner-occupied homes for the offers that matter. Our housing by town table shows how owner-occupied each town is, which is a quick way to judge how much an EDDM drop would reach renters.
Browse lists by town
Owner names and mailing addresses for every town and county in Long Island (Nassau and Suffolk), with owner-occupied and absentee filters.
Browse lists by town →